1. Know your three main types
Polysulphide (the traditional brown or white 'boat life' type): slow curing, flexible for years, sticks well to wood and is the classic choice for deck seams and bedding on wooden boats.
Polyurethane: much stronger and more adhesive — a sealant and a glue in one. Excellent below the waterline and on hull joints, but fittings bedded with it can be very hard to remove later.
Butyl tape: never fully cures, stays soft, and is ideal for deck fittings, windows and hatches you expect to take off again. Not for underwater seams.